$100,000 Frisco Pedestrian Settlement After a Drunk Driver Hit Our Client in a Parking Garage
J. Alexander Law Firm recovered $100,000 for a pedestrian hit by a drunk driver in a Frisco parking garage. The driver’s State Farm policy had a $30,000 limit. State Farm ignored our Stowers demand, then paid more than three times that limit to avoid a lawsuit.
The $100,000 is gross. Fees, case expenses and medical payments came out before our client was paid.
Case Snapshot
| Detail | This case |
|---|---|
| Location | Blue Star parking garage, 3610 Avenue of Champions, Frisco, Collin County |
| Fault | Driver charged with DWI |
| Injuries | Concussion, neck, back, knee and wrist pain, and a C5-C6 annular tear with a 2 mm herniation |
| Medical bills | $46,364 claimed ($51,850 billed) |
| Result | $100,000 from State Farm, before suit |
How the Crash Happened
At 2:38 a.m. on December 10, 2022, our client was walking through the Blue Star garage, about 230 feet north of Winning Drive, when a driver heading down the exit ramp hit him. Witnesses told paramedics the car was going 12 to 20 mph and that he flipped over it. Frisco police charged the driver with DWI and listed no contributing factor for our client.
Read the Redacted Frisco Crash ReportHis Experience
“I kept going to work after the crash because I couldn’t afford not to. My back and leg hurt every shift, and I missed therapy because I couldn’t lose the hours.”
Paramedics found him confused on the garage floor and took him to the ER as a trauma alert. Within days, pain ran from his low back down his right leg. He kept working, and the lost income and his work schedule made therapy hard to attend. By February he still could not kneel.
Treatment
| Date | Care and findings |
|---|---|
| Dec. 10, 2022 | ER: scans showed no acute injury, and a concussion was diagnosed |
| Dec. 14 | Pain management: low back pain into the right leg, and therapy ordered |
| Dec. 19 to Feb. 10 | 7 of 18 ordered therapy visits, with a four week gap |
| Mar. 1, 2023 | Neck MRI: C5-C6 annular tear, 2 mm herniation. Knee MRI normal |
| Mar. 2 | Still symptomatic, and a wrist MRI ordered (last record) |
How We Built the Claim
Josh Alexander made each decision below, as documented in the claim file and his letter to State Farm.
The Stowers Demand
His bills exceeded the $30,000 limit, so on June 15, 2023, we demanded the limit under the Stowers doctrine, with a July 5 deadline. In Texas, an insurer that fails to accept a reasonable demand within its limit can be liable for a judgment above that limit. State Farm never answered.
The Post Stowers Demand
On July 13, we demanded $100,000 by July 21, with no extensions, and said we would otherwise sue in Collin County for more than $500,000. Any judgment above $30,000 was now State Farm’s risk, so it paid the full amount, and our client avoided the time and cost of a lawsuit.
The Weak Spots
The 232 page demand package included what State Farm could use against the claim: a blood alcohol level of 122 mg/dL at the ER, conflicting records on loss of consciousness, back pain he denied at the scene, missed therapy and a normal knee MRI. The neck MRI and his pain management physician’s causation opinion carried the claim.
Hit by a Driver While Walking?
If the driver’s policy is smaller than your medical bills, a Stowers demand may get you past the limit. Tell us what happened and send any letters from the insurer.
Get a Free Review of Your ClaimSources and Attorney Review
| Source | What it supports |
|---|---|
| Certified Frisco Police crash report | Time, place, DWI charge |
| EMS and medical records (232 page demand package) | Witness accounts, treatment, imaging, blood alcohol, bills |
| July 13, 2023 letter to State Farm | Stowers dates, $30,000 limit, $100,000 demand |
| Firm’s claim file and attorney review | Settlement and demand strategy |
| Client’s signed statement | His quote and consent to publish medical details |
No court decided fault, causation or damages, and a DWI charge is not a conviction. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
