Does a traffic ticket prove the other driver was at fault after a Texas car accident?

Josh Alexander, Founder and Managing Attorney at J. Alexander Law Firm

Written by

Josh Alexander

Founder and Managing Attorney

Matthew Graham, Managing Litigation Attorney at J. Alexander Law Firm

With

Matthew Graham

Managing Litigation Attorney

By Josh Alexander, J. Alexander Law Firm | Updated

Short answer

Is the driver who got the ticket automatically at fault?

No. A ticket means the officer alleges a violation. For your injury claim, we must prove who caused the crash.

No, a ticket alone does not automatically establish who caused a Texas car crash. A ticket is an officer's charge that a driver broke a rule. A ticket can point us in a direction, but we still need to prove who caused your injuries. To pursue negligence per se, we need evidence that a driver violated a traffic law, whether or not an officer wrote a ticket. So our team starts gathering proof right away of what the rule required, what the driver did and how that caused the wreck.

What does the insurer consider?

The insurer for the other motorist may look at both drivers' accounts, the vehicle damage, the crash report and the ticket before a lawsuit. If your case reaches a Texas civil trial, though, the jury generally will not hear about the ticket, so I do not build a case on it. Our team gathers proof of the violation itself and how it helped cause the wreck.

Can the insurer still blame you?

While Matthew Graham handled ticket disputes for drivers and their insurers, he saw claims continue after the insured driver received a ticket. Both sides kept arguing over what caused the wreck and how much blame belonged to the other driver.

A citation against that driver can still leave you facing blame from an insurance adjuster. Our team gathers proof to answer that argument before an offer arrives.

What does negligence per se mean in a Texas car accident?

A safety law that applies to your claim can set the standard for how a driver should act. Even if a driver broke it without a legal excuse, I still need to prove that violation caused the wreck.

Negligence and negligence per se differ in how the standard for careful driving is set.

Two ways to set the standard

Ordinary negligence

  • In an ordinary negligence claim, jurors decide how a careful driver would have acted in the same situation.

Negligence per se

  • For negligence per se, the court may hand jurors a ruler instead: a clear road safety rule meant to protect people like you. That rule helps your case by spelling out what careful driving required. For example, in Impson v. Structural Metals, the court used a rule against driving on the left within 100 feet of an intersection rather than asking jurors to judge that move by ordinary care. I still have to show the driver broke that rule without a valid excuse and that it caused the crash. Most Texas Supreme Court cases on negligence per se have involved traffic rules.

An example

A violation must cause the crash

Imagine that a driver whose registration has expired hits your car from behind. He broke a law, but the expired tag did not cause the crash.

Even without a ticket, I look for proof of the violation in a report, video, witness account, photo or the driver's words.

What traffic violations count as negligence per se in Texas?

We first check whether the traffic rule gives drivers a specific instruction. If the rule simply calls for safe or reasonable driving, we consider what a cautious driver would have done in those circumstances.

Texas courts have interpreted the four rules in the table differently. First, I compare each rule's requirements with evidence of the driver's actions.

How the rules differ

  • Failure to yield

    A failure to yield can count, as our guide to Texas failure to yield crashes explains.

  • Speed

    Speed is different. For crashes involving a speeding driver, the evidence must show what speed would have been safe for the conditions that day.

  • Truck regulations

    Some regulations also set standards for negligence per se. After a truck wreck, we request records to check a truck driver's logged hours.

  • Following distance

    In Pearson v. DeBoer, a Corpus Christi appeals court treated the following distance rule as a duty to use ordinary care, not as negligence per se. That means we ask whether the driver left as much space as a careful person would have left.

    In one of our rear end claims with no police report, our fault argument relied on Pearson. We built that claim on the fact that our client's car was stopped and on photos showing its crushed rear.

How Texas courts read four traffic rules | Each row is taken from the opinion named in it, read on the Texas courts site on November 11, 2026.
Traffic rule, as the court described itHow the court treated itOpinion
Speed: no faster than is reasonable and prudent under the circumstancesThe injured driver had to provide evidence of a prudent speed for the conditions but had noneLozada v. Posada, Texas Supreme Court, 2025
Keep to the roadway's right side and move between lanes only when safeA rule requiring safe driving calls for reasonable care, so the judge did not instruct the jury that breaking it was negligence by itselfLakey v. Cauley, Houston court of appeals, 2001
Emergency vehicle may pass a red light after slowing as necessary for safe operationA more exact statement of ordinary reasonable care, not a separate standardCity of Houston v. Manning, Texas Supreme Court, 2025
Reckless driving, defined by wilful or wanton disregard for safetyThe injured person has to meet that recklessness standardManning (same 2025 opinion)

Can you be at fault and not get a ticket in a Texas car accident?

Yes. Without a ticket, a driver can still cause a crash, and I can still file an injury claim. When no ticket is issued, I still have to prove fault.

Claims without a listed charge

  • Garland intersection

    In the Garland intersection crash, a pickup hit our client's SUV while she was alone in it. Her SUV then struck two other vehicles.

    The officer reported that her light was green and that the pickup entered against a red light. The officer noted a factor for the pickup, but listed none for our client.

    No one received a citation, yet her injury claim continued. Before a lawsuit, the pickup driver's liability insurer paid all available coverage, and her underinsured motorist insurer paid its full limit.

  • Coppertowne Lane

    In the Coppertowne Lane pedestrian claim, the officer assigned the pickup driver a contributing factor, and the charges section had no entry.

Crash report instructions

A factor is not a charge

TxDOT's crash report instructions say an officer "may not have enough evidence to file a traffic charge, but does have enough data to render an opinion as to the contributing factors of the crash." In other words, an officer can identify what contributed to a crash without charging anyone.

We start with the officer's opinion, but we also investigate what happened.

Drivers with factors and no charges

  • 2,116

    In crashes with deaths

    For the period starting January 1, 2026, and ending November 9, our count includes Texas drivers involved in reportable crashes. In fatal crashes, officers marked a contributing factor for the vehicles of 2,504 drivers. For 2,116 of those drivers, the report's charge field showed "no charges".

  • 6,595

    In suspected serious injury crashes

    For 11,544 drivers in crashes where a suspected serious injury was the worst injury reported, officers listed a factor that contributed to the crash for their vehicles. Among those drivers, the charge field read "no charges" for 6,595.

The data do not say why the field reads that way or which drivers died. TxDOT says a report supplement should include charges filed later, so we look for one. The counts will likely grow as more reports come in.

Callers often do not know whether anyone got a citation, so our intake team asks early. The report's codes and description are the officer's opinion, not a citation. I review them and can walk through the report with you using our tool for understanding Texas crash reports.

The physical evidence needs to be checked against what the officer concluded. Matthew says officers lean on unwritten rules of thumb, such as usually blaming the left turning driver. One caller described the officers' decision this way:

Drivers whose vehicle had a contributing factor on the report, by what the charge field shows (Texas, 2026 crashes to November 9) | TxDOT CRIS public query, January 1 to November 9, 2026, pulled November 12, 2026
CrashDrivers with a contributing factor listedCharge field reads NO CHARGESAny other entry
Fatal crashes2,5042,116388
Suspected serious injury crashes11,5446,5954,949

Drivers include motorcycle operators. A contributing factor here means Contributing Factor 1, 2 or 3, the fields for what the officer felt contributed to the crash. Any other entry counts every other text in the charge field. Most name a charge, but some do not. In fatal crashes these were NONE, N/A, PENDING, PENDING INV, CHARGES PENDING and TBD, one each. In suspected serious injury crashes they were NONE (15), PENDING (3), and NO CHARGE, NO CHARGES AT THIS TIME, NO CITATION ISSUED DUE TO HIGHER CHARGE, CHARGES DECLINED BY DA, PENDING INVESTIGATION, PENDING WARRANT SUBMISSION and TBD, one each.

Matthew Graham, Managing Litigation Attorney at J. Alexander Law Firm
From our attorney

"They're taught, for instance, at the academy to put the at fault driver, who they think's at fault, in the unit one position."

Matthew Graham

Managing Litigation Attorney | Answering client questions on camera, 2026

From our intake

"They leave that to the insurance company. They don't place any fault with either one of us a ticket or nothing like that."

A caller, 2026

Crash report in hand and no ticket on it? Read the factor codes with me.

Call 469-807-7480

Why did I get a citation after an accident?

The officer believed you committed a traffic or insurance offense. Who caused the crash is a separate question, and a citation unrelated to the collision says nothing about its cause.

Lake June Road

A citation about insurance

In the Lake June Road claim with two conflicting accounts, our client was turning right at a Dallas intersection in rain and darkness when a pickup and her sedan ran into each other. The pickup driver said his light showed yellow, and our client told the officer the right of way belonged to her.

The officer could not tell who caused the crash and cited our client for having no insurance. The citation was about her insurance coverage, not what caused the wreck.

Before the claim reached court, the insurer for the pickup driver paid our client the bodily injury limit of his policy. Our client's claim ended in a settlement rather than a court ruling.

What if the citation concerns the collision?

When your citation concerns how the collision happened, I prepare to answer a claim that you share responsibility. If you believe you contributed to the collision, see our answer on getting help when you caused the wreck.

Does the firm handle tickets?

Some callers ask us to handle the ticket itself. We tell them our work is handling injury claims from crashes rather than traffic tickets.

Your citation

Before you decide how to plead

Tell me about any citation when we first talk, so I can see whether it concerns how the wreck happened. Let me see the citation and its court date before you decide how to plead. Your plea can affect your injury claim.

Handed a citation at the scene? Let's look at it together before the court date.

Call 469-807-7480

Can a traffic ticket be used as evidence in a Texas car accident case?

Generally not at trial. In a civil case about the same crash, Texas courts generally keep the ticket itself from the jury. We prepare with that in mind.

Does the driver's plea matter?

How the driver responded to a ticket matters more than the ticket itself. If properly proven, a guilty plea may be admitted as the driver's own statement.

Under Texas Rule of Evidence 410, a civil case cannot use a no contest plea against the person who made it. Article 27.02(5) of the Texas criminal procedure code makes the same distinction.

It treats a no contest plea like a guilty plea in criminal court, but not as an admission in a civil suit over the same act.

What if the driver pays the fine?

Many drivers simply pay the fine. When a traffic misdemeanor carries only a fine as punishment, paying it counts as a finding of guilt, as if the driver had pleaded no contest. Article 27.14(c) sets out that rule.

What information is barred from trial?

Another rule bars a civil trial from using a person's crash report answer about whether they want lawyers or other professionals to contact them. That rule comes from Section 550.066.

Proof beyond the plea

A red light example

Suppose the other driver gets a citation for going through a red light, then pleads no contest and pays the fine. The plea should stay out of your injury trial. I would prove the light violation with the crash report, any video and accounts from drivers or bystanders who saw it.

We start the injury claim without waiting for traffic court. If the citation is for failing to yield, our explanation of Texas crashes involving a failure to yield covers the rules behind it.

What are the defenses to negligence per se in Texas?

The main defense is that the driver had a legal excuse for breaking the rule. If the excuse is accepted, the violation alone does not prove the driver was careless. We compare the claimed excuse with physical evidence from the crash.

The Impson list

Reasons a violation may be excused

Texas recognizes a short list of reasons that can excuse a driver from following a rule. In Impson v. Structural Metals, the Texas Supreme Court adopted that list in 1972.

An incapacity may have made the violation reasonable, or the driver may not have known and had no reason to know when the rule applied. The driver may have been unable to comply even after taking reasonable care, faced an emergency the driver did not cause, or faced a greater risk of harm by following the rule.

If the other side offers an excuse, I first identify which of the five reasons they give. Then I check it against the physical evidence.

Two cases involving sudden events

  • A tire loses air

    Lozada v. Posada, decided in 2025, shows why an excuse matters. Two tractor trailers collided on Interstate 10 in fog.

    One driver said a new tire rapidly lost air and pulled his rig to the right. His truck jackknifed across both lanes, and the other truck hit it.

    The injured driver cited speed and parking rules but offered only the first driver's testimony and two photos. The court found no evidence that the first driver breached his duty.

    Because a wreck by itself does not prove careless driving, our team brings proof of what the driver did.

  • Headlights on a dark road

    In Lakey v. Cauley, headlights aimed from the shoulder of a dark road blinded a driver, who swerved into a disabled car parked there. The jury received an instruction about a sudden emergency and found the driver was not negligent.

    A Houston appeals court upheld that finding in 2001. If jurors believe a driver's account of an emergency, they can find that the driver was not negligent.

Matthew Graham recognizes arguments about a blowout or sudden emergency. In his old defense practice, he raised those arguments for insurers when the facts allowed.

To check what happened before the collision, our team starts looking for physical evidence early. In Lozada v. Posada, the Texas Supreme Court pointed to photos and witness testimony as evidence that could have challenged the driver's account.

The witnesses could include the injured person or someone trained in a field such as crash reconstruction.

Their insurer says a blowout caused the wreck? Walk me through the seconds before the impact.

Call 469-807-7480

How do you prove negligence after a Texas car accident with no ticket?

We start with the kind of evidence that could support a ticket, including the crash report, video, witness accounts and photos.

A caller told us the dash cam captured an officer explaining why the other driver did not get a citation. Our litigation paralegals request the original recording with its audio, and we keep it because the defense can question a trimmed or copied clip. Along with the recording, these are other things to save:

Talk with me first if you plan to discuss the ticket with the other driver's insurer. Our Texas crash evidence checklist has more ways to save useful material.

Based on your circumstances, you may seek damages for emotional anguish, physical pain, pay missed during time off work and medical bills. A filing deadline applies, and our page on Texas injury filing deadlines explains it.

24/7 | Free consultation | No fee unless we win

Let me see your crash report, whether anyone got a ticket or not.

J. Alexander Law serves injured clients throughout Texas: Dallas | Houston | San Antonio | Fort Worth | Arlington | Canton. Se habla español.